Centrifugal Pumps vs. Diaphragm Pumps
Time to Read: 0m 0s
There are a variety of pumps to choose from for fluid handling applications. Centrifugal pumps and diaphragm pumps offer different functionalities to best suit the needs of your application, from viscous and thick fluids to clean, thin fluids. Determining the right pump for your operation should evaluate your needs and the capabilities of a pump design. We’re discussing the differences between centrifugal pumps vs. diaphragm pumps to help you decide.
What is a Centrifugal Pump?
Centrifugal pumps use rotational energy from an impeller to move fluid through the system. It increases the velocity of the fluid to convert kinetic energy into pressure, primarily designed for low-viscosity, non-abrasive fluids with efficient and continuous operation.What is a Diaphragm Pump?
Diaphragm pumps use a flexible diaphragm to expand and contract a chamber to move fluids through suction and discharge valves. It is a positive displacement design that is ideal for viscous, abrasive, or chemical fluids, offering self-priming and dry-running capabilities for a variety of fluid processing and handling applications.Differences in Centrifugal Pumps vs. Diaphragm Pumps
Depending on the needs of your operation, centrifugal pumps and diaphragm pumps offer different capabilities. It is necessary to evaluate the design, functionality, fluid compatibility, energy efficiency and consumption, maintenance, and longevity of each pump configuration to find a suitable option for your applications.Design and Operation
The design and operation of centrifugal pumps and diaphragm pumps differ significantly. Centrifugal pumps utilize a rotating impeller to infuse kinetic energy into the fluid and convert it into pressure as the fluid moves out through the pump casing. This design offers continuous flow depending on the impeller speed. On the other hand, diaphragm pumps operate by using a reciprocating diaphragm to alternately compress and expand a chamber, displacing the fluid with each stroke. The positive displacement mechanism provides a pulsating flow for versatile fluid types.Fluid Compatibility
Each pump is designed for a particular type of fluid. With an open-impeller design, centrifugal pumps are best suited for operations handling low-viscosity fluids that are not abrasive or chemically aggressive, as they will damage the impeller. Diaphragm pumps utilize positive displacement and a diaphragm mechanism to handle a broader range of fluid types, including viscous, solid-laden, or corrosive fluids.Efficiency and Energy Consumption
Diaphragm pumps and centrifugal pumps differ in their efficiency and energy consumption due to their design and operation requirements. For steady, high-volume applications, centrifugal pumps offer high efficiency through smooth operation that has less friction and fewer moving parts, while diaphragm pumps tend to consume more energy. The positive displacement design of diaphragm pumps requires more effort to move thicker fluids, resulting in higher energy consumption because of their pulsating motion and air/electric attachment requirements.Maintenance and Longevity
Essential to pump operations, both centrifugal pumps and diaphragm pumps will require some level of maintenance. Centrifugal pumps typically have fewer moving parts and are easier to maintain, but critical components like the impeller and seals will require routine maintenance to ensure performance. Alternatively, diaphragm pumps are durable, excelling in applications with harsh conditions, but will need diaphragm and valve replacements.When to Choose a Centrifugal Pump for Your Operations
Centrifugal pumps are designed to efficiently handle large volumes of liquid with minimal energy consumption and wear. This type of fluid pump can be used across industries because of its success in the following operations:- High-flow, low-viscosity liquid applications
- For continuous operations with minimal pulsation
- HVAC, irrigation, and general fluid transfers
When to Use a Diaphragm Pump in Your Applications
Featuring a positive displacement configuration, diaphragm pumps deliver reliable flow in challenging conditions. They offer functional capabilities not found in centrifugal pumps or more vigorous applications where safety and durability are required, such as:- Operations with abrasive, viscous, or chemically aggressive fluids
- Applications where self-priming and dry-running is needed
- Chemical processing, sludge handling, and hazardous fluid transfers